Should Blackberry users be worried?
Blackberry appeal rejected by Supreme Court: Should you be worried? Bluntly? I’d have to say no. First of all, the technology in question can definitely be worked around. But given the infrastructure and rollout costs in that approach combined with NTP’s statements that they would be willing to settle for a royalty percentage that is below the maximum laid out at one time by the presiding judge (the initial amount awarded was around 5.7% but was later increased over 8%, NTP says they’ll take the 5.7%) indicates to me that this is just a question of money. If you do the math involved with the royalty percentage and look at RIM’s sales that involved the allegedly infringed patent it should be somewhere just north of $200 million. A great deal of the focus has been on the patent issues, primarily those involving the fact that RIM is effectively in Canada thus certain jurisdictional issues and those involving small 'patent holding' groups which don't produce any products much less develop anything threatening infringement lawsuits against massive companies that do their own R&D and actually manufacture a product or service. To the consumer of the Blackberry service I say that these issues are great discussions of legal theory but mean nothing. What matters to the consumers is whether or not they continue to get service, and if so does it impact what they have to pay for it. Well, let's take a look. Is RIM going to let their service be shut down for ~$200 million? Nope. In fact RIM had already offered to payoff NTP for around $400 million last year, and NTP had agreed, but the presiding judge wouldn’t approve it. So, back to this service shutdown thing, we know that RIM will payoff the lawsuit and we also know that NTP will accept a payoff. What we don’t know is whether or not a judge will approve it so let’s analyze that aspect of the situation. At this point now that primary appeals are over I suspect that what you’ll find is that a judge will be much, much, more likely to approve any amount that both parties will agree to. Why? Because what isn’t commonly known is that a vast number (north of 1 Million) of federal officials, emergency/disaster management services, and even law enforcement groups, use the Blackberry service for coordination during disasters as well as more monotonous, but essential, services. What this basically means is that enough political pressure will be applied to the judge that approving an amenable settlement should be considered a given. (side note: there is also some question about whether or not a federal judge could legally turn off the service for the federal workers anyway, so if you add that complexity to the mix it makes it all the more likely that a settlement offer would be approved to avoid the federal usage issues altogether) End result, RIM offers money, NTP accepts money, Judge frowns but signs off on agreement, transaction is taken into account on the market and absorbed via the already reduced stock price, and Blackberry users never experience so much as a blip in their service. My .02 cents anyway. Hey, at least I have the guts to make predictions that will very publicly be proven right or wrong :)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home