Thursday, February 23, 2006

Cellular FAQ

Cellular FAQ: Accessing the internet via cellular service and related questions.

As we continually are getting requests from our clients on how to connect their laptop to the internet via cellular services while on the road, which provider to use, etc. I thought I’d summarize options that exist today and our recommendations based on the current state of the carrier networks.

First, this acronym laden space can be incredibly confusing, sometimes misleading, and the options, plans, and phones/cards required to pull it off successfully can be daunting when presented to the non-geek.  Rather than dive into the technicalities first, I’ll simply make our recommendations based on a couple of user criteria since that’s what most of our clients really care about.

User Criteria:  “I just want the best speed and ease of use available today in the U.S.”
Recommendation:  Get a Verizon PC Data Card on their EV-DO network and their unlimited data plan.  This option requires its own contract and so is completely separate from any other carriers package you may currently have, therefore having an existing Verizon account or phone is not a requirement.  You should only get a 1 year contract as it is likely that by the end of 2006 Cingular will have deployed a software upgrade to its UMTS service finally providing equal or better speed with better coverage.  With the PC card option there is no need to worry about configuring the connection between a phone and your laptop and it’s much easier to just ‘connect and go’.  In addition you don’t have the concern of making a voice call on your cell phone at the same time you are online.

User Criteria:  “I want the least expensive option available for accessing the internet over high speed cellular data networks”
Recommendation:  If you have a cell phone with Bluetooth or a data cable that can operate as a cellular modem you can use your existing cell phone and plan instead of a separate PC Card to make the connection between your laptop and the internet.  Speeds vary widely between the type of device, the data protocols supported by the carrier and phone, and the coverage/data packages for the various protocols amongst the carriers vary as well.  Because the focus for this criterion is cost we recommend sticking with your current carrier.  Unfortunately due to all the variables involved, even amongst a single carrier, there is no simple way for us to recommend a single specific carrier, protocol, data plan, etc.  In general however if you are choosing a carrier at this moment and not stuck in an existing contract we’d recommend a Cingular EDGE-capable phone or one of the few UMTS-capable phones, and Bluetooth capability.  This isn’t the absolute fastest data connection available (EV-DO is currently) but offers the best combination of national coverage, data plan price (sometimes not necessary), and availability of ‘world phone’ devices for the global devices.  In addition, the Cingular UMTS service will be upgraded within the year to exceed the current EV-DO speeds so it makes it a relatively future-proof decision.

User Criteria:  “My contract is up and I’m evaluating carriers and phones, who should I go with?”
Recommendation:  This is truly a difficult decision due to the vast array of variables each user has (region, travel habits, budget, devices, corporate network requirements, etc.) and the more subjective issue of user preferences when it comes to type and look of a phone, which may not be available at the best carrier for you.  Since I committed earlier to leaving out all of the technicalities, and with the caveat that this recommendation is geared to the business user who travels somewhat regularly, here we go with our pick of the best carrier.  
Currently, and for the foreseeable future, Cingular has the best combination of options and is the leader in the ‘all-important’ category of coverage area.  
The purchase process amongst most users starts with choosing the best phone for them, and then simply going to whatever carrier has that particular phone.  We respectfully disagree with this approach.  We believe that you should choose your carrier first and then choose a compatible device from that carrier.  New phones are released every week, and there is a constant back-and-forth at play between the carriers in having the latest and greatest device, if another carrier has a phone you really like today…trust us, the opposite carrier will release one better very, very soon.  You *always* need coverage and reliability however and in this area Cingular truly shines, combine that with their defined plans for their cellular infrastructure in the future and you have the best of both worlds.  Note that we only consider objective criteria that has been published as fact for making our recommendations, I currently use Cingular personally but cell service at my home (in a major metropolitan area) is absolutely horrid.  This is due to an anomaly of factors that makes service within 100 yards of my home terrible and perfect anywhere outside that area, I understand however that this has nothing to do with Cingular and everything to do with geography and the unfortunate behavior of radio waves so allowing individual experiences to take part in these recommendations just wouldn’t make sense.  That said, use my experience as a guide and insure that in the areas in which you spend the most time (your office, your home, that apartment you keep your mistress in, etc.) you invite a friend over who uses the carrier/device you are considering and make sure it works to your satisfaction.  While I’m forced to make recommendations on the more general macro-scale, in the end your post-purchase happiness will be formed at a very personal level.

Notes: This area is almost as bad as the ‘Mac vs. PC’ topic when it comes to opinions and user loyalty so we have no doubt that there are a million questions and disagreements brewing in regards to our statements above.  Particularly when you add phones into the mix, which we have attempted to avoid.  If you are wondering why we didn’t address phone devices it’s because it is such a fluid, constantly changing, space and any recommendation made today would need to be thrown out a few weeks from now.  The above recommendations are meant to give single, simple answers to complex problems.  As consultants that is our jobs.  Rest assured that we evaluated all existing information in this space that we could get our hands on as well as reviewed the opinions of others that we respect in this field.  We had our own internal and external debates on the topics, sometimes heated, but always respectful.  If you agree or disagree, would like more info on how we arrived at a particular conclusion, or have a specific situation that you would like us to address feel free to provide a comment below.



Technical Roundup: Getting to know the technology
     
Voice quality has long been the primary concern of most mobile-phone users. But with a rise in the popularity of advanced smartphones as well as new interest in receiving audio and video streams on mobile devices, speed is likely to become a critical issue for those deciding which wireless provider to pick.
The problem is that, when talking about the delivery of data over cellular networks, it is not so easy to sort through the maze of technical terms and acronyms. In particular, those interested in getting better data rates should become familiar with the two most popular high-speed services -- EDGE (Enhanced Data for Global Evolution) and EVDO (Evolution Data Optimized) -- as well as the even faster mobile offerings that lie just on the horizon.
And it is also important to know that neither EVDO nor EDGE truly qualifies as broadband. "High-speed broadband implies that you have a fairly high-speed uplink, which in wired systems runs at 256 Kbps on the upload and 1.5 Mbps down," said Phillip Redman, research vice president at Gartner. "In wireless today, we see actual download speeds in the 300 to 500 Kbps range, but all the uplink speeds are less than 100 Kbps."
Need for Speed
In addition, trying to compare the two most popular high-speed wireless technologies, EVDO with EDGE, is like trying to compare apples to oranges. "EVDO offers download speeds of 400 to 700 Kbps, while EDGE delivers 100 to 130 Kbps, so EVDO has the speed edge today," observed Shiv Bakhshi, director of wireless infrastructure at the research firm IDC. "The better comparison is between EVDO and HSDPA (high-speed downlink packet access), which gets you data download speeds of 700 to 900 Kbps."
Cingular currently is rolling out HSDPA in several cities around the U.S., but it won't be available nationwide for quite some time.
Lisa Pierce, a vice president in the telecom and networks research group at Forrester Research, said people should not get mired in the technical specs just yet. "Speed is an important issue, and, as is true for any wireless technology, we can talk about throughput, about downlink and uplink speeds, improvement through compression, and so on. But the first thing consumers should ask about is availability, then follow up by asking questions about speed and setup."
So far, most cellular customers tend to favor the data services of their current voice provider. "They have already made the decision that their current voice coverage is sufficient," Pierce said. "So if it's Cingular, then they are looking at EDGE, or if it's Verizon or Sprint, then they are looking at EVDO."
The one advantage of EDGE, said Gartner's Redman, is that the coverage is much better than you see for EVDO. "EDGE coverage is available in the majority of markets, whereas, with EVDO, the coverage is only about 50 to 60 percent and mainly in metropolitan areas."
Origins of EDGE and EVDO
The two fundamental cellular transmission technologies at work in the U.S. today are known as CDMA (Code Division Multiple Access) and GSM (Global System for Mobile Communication). EVDO is a CDMA derivative, whereas EDGE is an offshoot of GSM.
"Because GSM is more widely deployed worldwide, EDGE is more widely available today," Bakhshi said. "And if you are a traveler going to Europe and you have an EVDO phone, that phone won't work over there." Bakhshi also pointed out that EDGE is designed to fall back to GSM if coverage is lacking, whereas EVDO falls back to CDMA, which is not as widely available. "Seventy percent of the world has GSM, while only roughly 20 percent of the world has CDMA."
Another cellular term that you will frequently encounter as you comparison-shop for high-speed wireless services is 3G, which is short for "third generation." How do EDGE and EVDO stack up against the 3G services available elsewhere in the world?
"In Europe, 3G is a frequency, not a technology," Redman said. "In the U.S., we don't have 3G frequencies assigned as such."
What Europeans consider to be 3G is actually based on the UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunications System) standard, which downloads data at 200 Kbps, Redman noted. "There is a technology coming that will increase UMTS downlink speeds to 1.8 Mbps initially and eventually to 14 Mbps, but right now UMTS is comparable to EDGE and EVDO."
The International Telecommunications Union considers EDGE and the latest version of CDMA, called 1xRTT (single-carrier Radio Transmission Technology), to be 3G, but most people in the cellular industry today do not really consider 1xRTT to be 3G, Bakhshi said.
However, he added, most industry insiders do regard EVDO and UMTS to be equivalent to 3G, while CDMA 1xRTT and EDGE are generally considered to be 2.5G services.
The Road Ahead
Cellular subscribers need to understand that the technology is going to be changing every couple of years and that a constant evolution will be underway between now and 2015. That means that dedicated mobile-speed freaks had better be prepared to change service providers and equipment frequently.
Moreover, the first big change is already on the doorstep. "Through the use of HSDPA technology, the UMTS technology to be introduced by Cingular Wireless will basically be brought on par with Verizon's EVDO," Pierce noted. "UMTS will be different from EDGE in much the same way that EVDO is different than CDMA x1RTT."
UMTS will essentially replace EDGE in the U.S. over time, although EDGE still will be available, Pierce offered. "Then, later on, Cingular has said in analyst sessions that it will be using high-speed uplink packet access (HSUPA) to improve speeds in the send direction."
With the right HSDPA/UMTS handset, you will be able to conduct simultaneous voice and data sessions, which is not the case today with CDMA 1xRTT, Pierce said. "There aren't a lot of dual-chip CDMA/EVDO devices out there yet to allow simultaneous sessions, but this should be a big market in 2006."
Ultimately, you will have to decide which system works best with your needs and budget. Cingular prices its data service at $80 per month for unlimited access, while Verizon prices its data service at $45 per month for unlimited access.
One thing to bear in mind, especially if you're on the market for a new notebook computer, is that laptop manufacturers already have begun to add the technology to their notebook lines, an addition that obviates the need for a separate PCMCIA card to connect to the service.
Sony, for example, has built in EDGE technology to the VAIO TX630P, making it a snap to get connected to the Internet far from a local Wi-Fi hotspot. Other laptop makers likely will follow suit.